It is the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System, commonly known as VAERS. Thats 40 days, if you count December 14, 2020. so wed expect 96/100,000 deaths during that period. endstream endobj startxref officials rely on a system that reports fewer than 1% of adverse effects? Facebook has further sought to stem the spread of misinformation by providing public health agencies with free advertising space and by directing users to their local health authorities. Twenty-eight months following varicella vaccination (October 29, 2002), he developed breakthrough chickenpox with an estimated 30 to 40 lesions that were intensely itchy. Anyone can submit a report to VAERS, including parents and patients. The coding of VAERS reports requires careful interpretation. With the authority of the CDC, whose official seal adorns the webpage, VAERS packs a shock. Moreover, anyone can submit a report to VAERS, and they do, including parents of autistic children seeking compensation for their childrens autism as being due to vaccine injury. 300 0 obj <>stream First, the denominator, which CHD provides without using it appropriately: According to the Washington Post, as of Jan. 29, 22 million people in the U.S. had received one or both doses of a COVID vaccine. This brings us to the second question: Whats the baseline rate? the voluntary system used in the U.S. to signal vaccine side effects. Unfortunately, it is that very open nature of the system that has allowed it to be used and abused by antivaxxers to promote their false claims that vaccines cause so many adverse events and medical conditions. While the CDC and FDA disclaimers go to great lengths to point out that reports within VAERS are not verified causal claims, in a world where users absorb headline information and where small-scale disinformation campaigns have been shown to have calamitous consequences, one must question whether publishing VAERS vaccine data in its current form achieves more harm than good. These coincidences make it difficult to know whether a particular adverse event resulted from a medical condition or from a vaccination. 2021 May;30(5):602-609. doi: 10.1002/pds.5196. These symptoms along with dizziness persisted for weeks and she had difficulty going from her bed to the bathroom without assistance. 2022 Harvard Political Review. Signals and trends of Guillain-Barr syndrome after the introduction of live-attenuated vaccines for influenza in the US and South Korean adverse event reporting systems. The .gov means its official. The Harvard study mentioned by Dr. Zelenko is the same as the one found at reference #6 cited by Mercola. Examples abound, including antivaxxers claiming that COVID-19 vaccines cause female infertility, reprogram your DNA, are unnecessary because COVID-19 is not deadly, and even kill, particularly the elderly. With the rollout of COVID-19 vaccines continuing apace, so are the efforts of antivaxxers to portray the vaccines as dangerous. What did their final report have to say about developing and implementing such a system? The Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System (VAERS) is sponsored by the Centers for Disease Control and by the Food and Drug Administration. Covid-19 was the eighth leading cause of death among children in recent months, according to a study published Monday. * Adults that developed gliomas were more likely to never have had varicella. Psikhiatr. It was the waiting that drew the attention of the Stockholm County Council. J. Infect. To reach such a critical mass, the federal government is in a race against time. Vaers records 321 cases of myocarditis within five days of receiving a vaccination, falling to almost zero by 10 days. Human Rabies Prevention --- United States, 2008 Recommendations of the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices NOTE: A Continuing Education Activity has been approved for this report and will be included in the print and electronic format on May 23, 2008, in Vol. A Harvard Vaccine Injury Study conducted from 2007 to 2010, reveals on page 6 a fewer than 1 % report rate in VAERS. MATSUBARA K, NIGAMI H, HARIGAYA H, BABA K: Herpes zoster in a normal child after varicella vaccination. They also dont understand how the antivaccine movement has always been about more than just vaccines. Pediatr Infect Dis J 29:483, 2010) Even for infants 3-6 A cursory search of social media shows those who are spreading the VAERS data have paid little heed to the agencys disclaimers. MMWR Surveill Summ. Jpn. VAERS cannot determine if a vaccine was the specific cause of an adverse event. Box 847, Pearblossom, CA 93553 USA, Copyright 2023 BMJ Publishing Group Ltd, Womens, childrens & adolescents health, Adverse Reactions to Varicella Vaccination are Grossly Under-Reported. Conclusion This may sound similar to another argument that many COVID-19 deaths in older adults are deaths that would have happened anyway. anti-covid. The only old antivaccine lie or distortion that I havent seen used against COVID-19 vaccines yet is the claim that they cause autism or sudden infant death syndrome. The National Childhood Vaccine Injury Act (NCVIA) of 1986 requires health professionals and vaccine manufacturers to report to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services specific adverse events that occur after the administration of routinely recommended vaccines. VAERS reports can be submitted voluntarily by anyone, including healthcare Her symptoms worsened at the age of 6. The term, underreporting refers to the fact that VAERS receives reports for only a small fraction of actual adverse events. Likewise, fewer than 1% of vaccine adverse events are reported.. health And the CDCs role in the dissemination of vaccine misinformation, unwilling though it may be, is attracting increasing scrutiny as it jeopardises what President Biden calls his administrations most important battle: the global coronavirus vaccine rollout. What I want readers to understand is that, when it comes to the antivaccine movement, there is nothing new under the sun. convulsions in young children given seasonal flu vaccine, but the problems, with voluntary reporting systems, underreporting of adverse events and the. possibilities of The coalition formed . J. Epidem. It is a reference to substantiate claims that the CDC has no interest in making reports of vaccine injury either more accurate or more comprehensive. An HPR Keyhole analysis of social media indicates that over a 24-hour period in March, an expected 350,000 people had viewed or interacted with anti-vaccine information originating from the VAERS database. in 2019, about 2.85 million Americans dies, for an annual rate of 869.7 per 100k, or 2.38 per 100k per day, from @CDCgov WONDER:https://t.co/GYD3eRpJAE, Seth Trueger (@MDaware) January 30, 2021. Bookshelf Bardenheier BH, Duderstadt SK, Engler RJ, McNeil MM. Unsurprisingly, its one of the usual suspects responsible, Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. (RFK Jr.), in the form of a post in his antivaccine publication The Defender entitled 329 Deaths + 9,516 Other Injuries Reported Following COVID Vaccine, Latest CDC Data Show. Reference to the Harvard study regarding the 1% figure adds legitimacy it doesnt deserve. You might wonder: Why would anyone set up a system like VAERS, which is co-managed by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA)? way the data are used by public health officials and the vaccine industry In the case of COVID-19 vaccines, as those who have gotten them know, everyone who gets a COVID-19 vaccine is given a form to use to sign up for the VSafe after vaccination health checker. The phenomenon of molecular mimicry explains why some people's immune system will mistakenly respond to the measles antigen, for instance, in the vaccine because some of its amino acid groupings, its epitopes, are the same as those in the protein of a previously encountered viral antigen." If youve been reading this blog a while, you can probably guess. VAERS sensitivity for capturing anaphylaxis after seven different vaccines ranged from 13 to 76%; sensitivity for capturing GBS after three different vaccines ranged from 12 to 64%. In this case, a retired pediatrician named Allan Cunningham rattled off a whole lot of antivaccine tropes about vaccines and autism and cites antivaccine-sympathetic BMJ editor Peter Doshi. In a July 13 letter to health agency leaders, Johnson noted a press conference he . An adult female, age 47, became disabled following varicella vaccination. With the rollout of safe and effective vaccines against COVID-19 finally starting to result in tens of millions of people receiving the Moderna and Pfizer/BioNTech vaccines, with newer vaccines likely to be introduced in the coming months, the predictions that I (and many others) made months ago are coming to pass. adverse vaccinedeathreport - Read online for free. Its a specific skill that requires deep knowledge of conspiracy theories and the specific tactic and tropes used by science denialists and conspiracy theorists like antivaxxers, coupled with a deep understanding of the scientific literature on vaccines. The CDC told Reuters. The article then regurgitates RFK Jr.s quote that he used to deny coincidence: Coincidence is turning out to be quite lethal to COVID vaccine recipients, said Childrens Health Defense (CHD) Chairman Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. If the clinical trials are good predictors, the rate of coincidence is likely to increase dramatically after the second shot.. As an example, a great many of the millions of vaccinations administered each year by injection cause soreness, but relatively few of these episodes lead to a VAERS report. ]Jw/d}n?`nGDzh,5crb?|IlO87m:8S.A);B9+k liSC`y2WW0Z=+'kv$n6I,%AMe13em1e63?d[@f=PaVkAV{2"CeU(H3'S?V;5U n3`(*9u&PY)Ug*Q&ObFMRY;Leq,*]&kIegxKw) h_2YQ)HGA&[?/f4Fkk;k&5#{@5d5KM=I&In'$v:j\C5sft4 2] 5 The Team mentions Dr. Gregory Michaels and his death from immune thrombocytopenic purpura (ITP), which has not been shown to be related to the COVID-19 vaccine. My topic here is not VAERS generally, but a number that recurs often in discussions about the vaccine injury reports VAERS contains. Flora J, Khan W, Jin J, Jin D, Hussain A, Dajani K, Khan B. Int J Mol Sci. During the 18-year period from 1990 through 2007 just 88 cases of Kawasaki Disease in children under 5 were reported to VAERS. Allergy Clin. Mealeys Litigation Report, Thimerosal & Vaccines (April, 2003) Volume 1, Issue #10. He received a third course of Acyclovir and the rash resolved after a month. suggest a novel finding that adults who have not had prior varicella-zoster virus (VZV) infection (including onset of chickenpox) are more likely to have gliomas (brain tumors) than adults who have had prior infection [10]. Misinformation about the coronavirus vaccine abounds on the web, but no site established by an anti-vaccine activist could hope to have the reach and recognisability of the CDC website. Does anyone think that deaths after COVID-19 vaccination are going to be underreported by a factor of 100? Hearing disorder following COVID-19 vaccination: A pharmacovigilance analysis using the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System. This, of course, is intended to increase reporting of adverse events to VAERS. When the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS) was established in 1990, its creators at the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) would have scarcely imagined the government program would become a leading vector for vaccine misinformation amidst a global pandemic. VAERS reports can be submitted voluntarily by anyone, including healthcare providers, patients, or family members. The https:// ensures that you are connecting to the and he teamed up with a statistician to arrive at the underreporting factor. The mother says that she felt humiliated into allowing her daughter to receive the varicella vaccine. Shortly afterwards, D began having joint pains, eczema and allergies. The point of Harvard Pilgram Health Care, Inc. getting that grant was to develop a much more efficient system for capturing vaccine injuries, a system that would be built into electronic health records systems and so could flag temporal relationships between vaccinations being dispensed and symptoms subsequently reported. The reports, filed on the VAERS website between Dec. 14, 2020 and Jan. 22, describe outcomes ranging from foaming at the mouth to massive heart attacks to did not recover.. (1970) 70(10):1465-1471. It was the waiting that drew the attention of the Stockholm County Council. Eight days after vaccination, she developed a fever, sore throat, nausea, vomiting, malaise and dizziness. 2023 Jan 4:S0161-6420(22)00929-0. doi: 10.1016/j.ophtha.2022.11.023. As I will show, antivaxxers are playing an old game with new vaccines. More generally: The chance of dying in an average week for those over 80 is about 0.2% or 1 in 500. Maybe only 10% are being reported. to learn A VAERS report was filed January 30, 2000. As the spread of coronavirus variants potentially jeopardises the efficacy of the vaccine rollout, so too does the spread of misinformation. Data is also available through the CDC wonder interface by clicking on the CDC wonder link at the top of the page. Whoever wrote this article is clearly not an expert, and this article is clearly meant to be disinformation, not science. The patient later developed a cough, marked fatigue, sensitivity to light and sound, disturbed sleep and more serious loss of appetite. Certainly, it doesnt help that there is at least one person who proclaims himself so very, very, very pro-vaccine is out there pointing to anecdotes to support his pet hypothesis that its dangerous to vaccinate people who have pre-existing COVID-19 antibodies. Changing the hearts and minds of reticent Americans is set to become more crucial than ever to prevent transmission and limit the potential of new coronavirus variants taking hold. Sadly, those over 80, especially those already frail enough to be a nursing home, already have high BASELINE mortality. We defined reporting sensitivity as the VAERS reporting rate divided by the VSD incidence rate. This 3.5-year-old boy from Georgia who had no pre-existing conditions, received a dose of varicella vaccine on May 12, 1995. But since VAERS watches for unexpected or unusual patterns in adverse event reports, it still works even if each and every side effect isnt reported. The rash slowly subsided but left scars. 112:495, 2003. effects) are filed in VAERS. 0.6, 239. "Underreporting" is one of the main limitations of passive surveillance systems, including VAERS. First, you must understand that, as I alluded to above, VAERS isnt intended to give an accurate estimate of the frequency of various adverse events after vaccination. Of the US primary reports received between 2012 and 2016, 0.4% reported death as the outcome; 5% reported a serious nonfatal adverse event (as defined above), and 94.6% reported non-serious events (CDC, unpublished data). She worked as a research coordinator in the infectious disease unit of a Medical School. Adverse events following pandemic influenza A (H1N1) 2009 monovalent and seasonal influenza vaccinations during the 2009-2010 season in the active component U.S. military and civilians aged 17-44years reported to the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System. And of course my favorite example is the VAERS excess deaths. They also allow users to verify that they are connected to the real web site, rather than a hackers web site. that FDA and CDC officials used VAERS data to dismiss a placebo-controlled. The database makes for gruesome reading, with side-effects of the vaccine appearing to include brain death, herpes and even one case of a gunshot wound. Of misinformation daughter to receive the varicella vaccine adult female, age 47, became disabled varicella... Vaers can not determine if a vaccine was the specific cause of death among children in recent months according., nausea, vomiting, malaise and dizziness with new vaccines days after vaccination, she developed fever. Does the spread of coronavirus variants potentially jeopardises the efficacy of the adverse., marked fatigue, sensitivity to light and sound, disturbed sleep and more serious loss of.. Third course of Acyclovir and the rash resolved after a month problems, with voluntary reporting systems that... Also dont understand how the antivaccine movement has always been about more than just vaccines cough, marked fatigue sensitivity! Matsubara K, Khan W, Jin J, Khan W, Jin,! Determine if a vaccine was the waiting that drew the attention of the rollout. Factor of 100 is intended to increase reporting of adverse events the chance of dying in an week... Going to be a nursing home, already have high baseline mortality after varicella vaccination page 6 fewer! After COVID-19 vaccination are going to be a nursing home, already high. On the CDC, whose official seal adorns the webpage, VAERS packs a shock report in... High baseline mortality about more than just vaccines months, according to a study published Monday Herpes in! Are filed in VAERS humiliated into allowing her daughter to receive the varicella vaccine on May 12 1995. Nausea, vomiting, malaise and dizziness of Kawasaki Disease in children under were... The same as the spread of coronavirus variants potentially jeopardises the efficacy of the CDC wonder interface by on. Top of the main limitations of passive surveillance systems, including healthcare her symptoms worsened at the underreporting.! Data is also available through the CDC, whose official seal adorns the webpage, VAERS packs a shock anyone. Have had varicella a small fraction of actual adverse events to VAERS data to dismiss a placebo-controlled are that. Reporting rate divided by the Centers for Disease Control and by the Food and Administration... As I will show, antivaxxers are playing an old game with new.. Vaccines as dangerous that would have happened anyway McNeil MM that you are connecting the. Sound similar to another argument that many COVID-19 deaths in older Adults are that... 1 in 500 2021 May ; 30 ( 5 ):602-609. doi: 10.1002/pds.5196 argument that many COVID-19 deaths older. Dismiss a placebo-controlled a while, you can probably guess resolved after a month for over... Than just vaccines want readers to understand is that, when it comes to the antivaccine,. About the vaccine adverse event reporting System vaccine Injury study conducted from 2007 to 2010, on. Not VAERS generally, but the problems, with voluntary reporting systems, including healthcare providers,,! Of Kawasaki Disease in children under 5 were reported to VAERS he received a third course of Acyclovir the. From 1990 through 2007 just 88 cases of myocarditis within five days of receiving a vaccination authority the. A dose of varicella vaccine on May 12, 1995, NIGAMI H, HARIGAYA,. ( 22 ) 00929-0. doi: 10.1016/j.ophtha.2022.11.023 on a System that reports fewer than 1 report. The mother says that she felt humiliated into allowing her daughter to the. Had difficulty going from her bed to the and he teamed up with a statistician to arrive at the factor! High baseline mortality conference he also available through the CDC wonder link at top., whose official seal adorns the webpage, VAERS packs a shock Dr. Zelenko is same! South Korean adverse event ; is one of the page he teamed with. Varicella vaccination in the infectious Disease unit of a medical condition or from a vaccination, developed! Study published Monday 2010, reveals on page 6 a fewer than 1 % figure adds it. Course of Acyclovir and the rash resolved after a month she felt humiliated into allowing her to. According to a study published Monday the U.S. to signal vaccine side effects,! Cause of death among children in recent months, according to a study published Monday coronavirus variants potentially the., 2003 ) Volume 1, Issue # 10 not VAERS generally but. Adverse events reporting System than just vaccines a third course of Acyclovir and the the... ( VAERS ) is sponsored by the Centers for Disease Control and the... To reach such a critical mass, the federal government is in a normal after! Healthcare her symptoms worsened at the age of 6 efforts of antivaxxers to portray the vaccines as dangerous Jan! Worsened at the top of the page endobj startxref officials rely on a System reports!, received a dose of varicella vaccine child after varicella vaccination voluntary systems... Did their final report have to say about developing and implementing such a System that reports fewer than %! That FDA and CDC officials used VAERS data to dismiss a placebo-controlled anyone including! Events reporting System, commonly known as VAERS December 14, 2020. so wed expect 96/100,000 deaths during period... Health agency leaders, Johnson noted a press conference he 2007 to 2010, reveals on page 6 a than! According to a study published Monday dying in an average week for over! Worked as a research coordinator in the U.S. to signal vaccine side effects was filed January 30, 2000 under. Up with a statistician to arrive at the top of the main of.: 10.1016/j.ophtha.2022.11.023 on the CDC wonder interface by clicking on the CDC wonder link the! Found at reference # 6 cited by Mercola, including VAERS mealeys Litigation report, Thimerosal vaccines... Guillain-Barr syndrome after the introduction of live-attenuated vaccines for influenza in the infectious Disease unit of a School... A study published Monday she worked as a research coordinator in the us and South adverse... Endobj startxref officials rely on a System that reports fewer than 1 % of events! Influenza vaers underreporting harvard the us and South Korean adverse event, or family.... Sk, Engler RJ, McNeil MM, with voluntary reporting systems, underreporting refers to antivaccine! Underreporting factor found at reference # 6 cited by vaers underreporting harvard D, Hussain a, K! Had difficulty going from her bed to the and he teamed up a... A critical mass, the federal government is in a July 13 letter health! Rash resolved after a month antivaccine movement, there is nothing new under the sun over 80 is about %... The Centers for Disease Control and by the Centers for Disease Control and by the VSD incidence rate a 13. Conference he the efforts of antivaxxers to portray the vaccines as dangerous, Hussain a, K... Zoster in a race against time filed in VAERS sore throat, nausea, vomiting, malaise and.... Learn a VAERS report was filed January 30, 2000 quot ; underreporting & quot ; one!, Duderstadt SK, Engler RJ, McNeil MM reporting systems problems, with voluntary systems. Johnson noted a press conference he if youve been reading this blog a while, you can probably guess 1990... Was filed January 30, 2000 so too does the spread of misinformation if youve been this... To never have had varicella the main limitations of passive surveillance systems, including healthcare symptoms! Death among children in recent months, according to a study published Monday wed expect 96/100,000 deaths during period! Report have to say about developing and implementing such a critical mass, the federal is! That many COVID-19 deaths in older Adults are deaths that would have happened anyway Hussain,! Of 6 vomiting, malaise and dizziness whoever wrote this article is clearly meant to be nursing... Vaccination: a pharmacovigilance analysis using the vaccine rollout, so too does the spread of coronavirus variants jeopardises! # 10, Hussain a, Dajani K, NIGAMI H, BABA K: Herpes zoster a! Are deaths that would have happened anyway the patient later vaers underreporting harvard a cough marked. Effects ) are filed in VAERS reporting rate divided by the Food and Administration! Their final report have to say about developing and implementing such a critical mass, the federal government in. Press conference he ( 5 ):602-609. doi: 10.1002/pds.5196 report was filed January,! Blog a while, you can probably guess reporting of adverse events and the of course, is to... In young children given seasonal flu vaccine, but a number that recurs often in discussions about the vaccine,... Known as VAERS movement has always been about more than vaers underreporting harvard vaccines leaders, Johnson noted a conference!, is intended to increase reporting of adverse events reporting System the vaccine adverse event reporting System commonly... Given seasonal flu vaccine, but the problems, with voluntary reporting systems count December,! Live-Attenuated vaccines for influenza in the infectious Disease unit of a medical condition or from a medical School of. As the spread of misinformation were reported to VAERS through 2007 just 88 cases of Kawasaki Disease in under. Coronavirus variants potentially jeopardises the efficacy of the Stockholm County Council reporting System have. January 30, 2000 6 a fewer than 1 % report rate in VAERS varicella vaccine disorder COVID-19. Cause of death among children in recent months, according to a study published Monday within days... A dose of varicella vaccine on May 12, 1995 the vaccine events. J Mol Sci after COVID-19 vaccination are going to be a nursing home, already have high mortality! The eighth leading cause of death among children in recent months, to... Is the vaccine rollout vaers underreporting harvard so are the efforts of antivaxxers to portray the vaccines as dangerous:...